Why do modern mass democracies so often turn to charismatic authoritarian leaders? How can we understand the desire for redemptive strongmen that repeatedly emerges in complex capitalist societies? And what does it mean when the figure of the monarch and that of the CEO become increasingly indistinguishable in the radical conservative imagination? Similar questions were at the forefront of intellectual debate a century ago. In the aftermath of World War I, critics from opposing ends of the political spectrum referred to the emergence of “men of destiny” amid social crisis and civilizational decline as “Caesarism.” For the conservative-revolutionary essayist Oswald Spengler, the rise of modern Caesars was the symptom of a cyclical phenomenon of cultural decline, the implosion of traditional institutions and the predominance of raw power politics. For the Marxist theorist Antonio Gramsci, drawing on Karl Marx’s anatomy of “Bonapartism,” contemporary Caesarism was an unstable fix to situations of “catastrophic equilibrium,” in which conflicting forces are unable to get the upper hand and risk generating a broader social collapse. While Caesarism could never fully resolve a crisis of hegemony, it could take “progressive” or “reactionary” forms, depending on whether it created the conditions for a revolutionary reconstruction of society on a new basis. But how useful is the concept of “Caesar”—repurposed from antiquity—for an understanding of industrial and post-industrial political dynamics? What can a study of the new Caesars teach us about the formation, structure, and pathologies of capitalist political modernity?
In this course we will explore the key features of Caesarisms past and present by grounding our analysis in the contrasting diagnoses of this phenomenon provided in Spengler’s The Decline of the West and Gramsci’s Prison Notebooks, as well as related texts from the interwar period. We will focus especially on how these crucial texts of revolutionary-communist and revolutionary-conservative thought understand the link between capitalism, crisis, and the forms of political power. We will then turn to critiques of political authority and leadership articulated from within the Black radical tradition, looking in particular at Cedric J. Robinson’s The Terms of Order. The course will conclude by considering how the prospect of a capitalist dictatorship or “CEO monarchy” has become explicit among thinkers of the contemporary far Right.
This course is available for "remote" learning and will be available to anyone with access to an internet device with a microphone (this includes most models of computers, tablets). Classes will take place with a "Live" instructor at the date/times listed below.
Upon registration, the instructor will send along additional information about how to log-on and participate in the class.